| 2012 |
| Daleigh Fossler |
McNeese State University |
D-I NCAA |
| Greta Smeins |
Morehead State University |
D-I NCAA |
| Kylee Polsley |
Chadron State College |
D-II NCAA |
| Cailin Simpson |
Rogers State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Breana Canova |
St. Cloud State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Kylee Simpson |
Wayne State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Jordan Kerns |
Morningside University |
NAIA |
| 2011 |
| Bradi Wall |
University of Iowa |
D-I NCAA |
| Logann Peterson |
Wayne State College |
D-II NCAA |
| 2010 |
| Camille Czarnecki |
Stetson University |
D-I NCAA |
| Angela Jay |
Chadron State College |
D-II NCAA |
| Stephanie Schmidt |
Wayne State College |
D-II NCAA |
| Kristen Martinson |
Wayne State College |
D-II NCAA |
| Natalie Ruechel |
Wayne State College |
D-II NCAA |
| Luisa Bar |
St. Gregory's University |
NAIA |
| 2009 |
| Toni Dance |
Missouri Western State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Casey Lucas |
California Baptist University |
NAIA |
| 2008 |
| Laura Wilcox |
Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis |
D-I NCAA |
| Samantha Tiefenthaler |
Grand Canyon University |
D-II NCAA |
| Samantha Buchanan |
Missouri Western State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Jenna Dell |
University of Nebraska-Omaha |
D-II NCAA |
| Katie Lefler |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Kimber Markley |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Kelsey Meyers |
Rogers State University |
NAIA |
| 2007 |
| Kora Behrens |
University of Central Arkansas |
D-I NCAA |
| Amanda Perrott |
University of Central Arkansas |
D-I NCAA |
| Kady Revis |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| 2006 |
| Skye Wakefield |
University of Nebraska-Kearney |
D-II NCAA |
| Katie Pfannenstiel |
University of Nebraska-Kearney |
D-II NCAA |
| Chanel Reaves |
University of Nebraska-Omaha |
D-II NCAA |
| Jennifer Strohman |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Sarah Walck |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Erica Zerkle |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Danielle Abrahamson |
Dickinson State University |
NAIA |
| 2005 |
| Lori Huelskamp |
Missouri Western State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Nicole Fringer |
Southwest Minnesota State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Nichole Kalasky |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Danica Ritchie |
Dickinson State University |
NAIA |
| Dara Ritchie |
Dickinson State University |
NAIA |
| 2004 |
| Channon Nitz |
Emporia State |
D-II NCAA |
| 2003 |
| Jackie Simon |
Indiana State University |
D-I NCAA |
| Dallas Wilson |
Southwest Minnesota State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Jackie Heeren |
Southwest Minnesota State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Courtney Sayre |
Southwest Minnesota State University |
D-II NCAA |
| Amber Terry |
University of South Dakota |
D-II NCAA |
| Tara Buckley |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| 2002 |
| Andrea Lockett |
University of Nebraska-Omaha |
D-II NCAA |
| 2001 |
| Mary Shea Carpenter |
St. John's University |
D-I NCAA |
| Andrea Hesse |
University of Nebraska-Omaha |
D-II NCAA |
| 2000 |
| Nicole Garber |
Creighton University |
D-I NCAA |
| Sandra Owen |
Peru State College |
NAIA |
| 1999 |
| Missy Griese |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Laura Emmole |
Grand View College |
NAIA |
| Sara Gaul |
Grand View College |
NAIA |
| 1998 |
| Valencia Moody |
University of Nebraska-Omaha |
D-II NCAA |
| Angie Urosevich |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Mary Greise |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Meaghan Shea |
Dana College |
NAIA |
| Heather Mueller |
Doane College |
NAIA |
| Heather Hobbs |
Doane College |
NAIA |
| 1996 |
| Jaimy Echternach |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Kathy Kent |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| Toshia Klinkefus |
Bellevue University |
NAIA |
| 1995 |
| Heidi Camenzind |
Midland Lutheran College |
NAIA |
| Kristine Hughes |
Peru State College |
NAIA |
| 1993 |
| Angie Louck |
Wayne State College |
D-II NCAA |
| Erin Godrey |
Benedictine College |
NAIA |
| 1992 |
| Brandyn Gerdes |
Kansas Wesleyan University |
NAIA |
| 1991 |
| Karen Wood |
Missouri Western University |
D-II NCAA |
